Quote:
Originally posted by WarChild
That makes no sense at all. The variables are not the same with two people.
One person selects two boxes (by actually selecting 1 box) while the other person is stuck with only 1 box.
Look at it like this: You are trying to select 1 winning item out of 3 possible choices. If I give you one unknown box and keep two for myself, who has the better odds of winning? I have two chances of winning and you only one.
Adding a fictional third person completely changes the equation.
|
exactly
because say the invisible man was sitting at the other empty box
when the host takes that box from the invisible man he cant just switch boxes
thats not the fucking point