Wow, that is some ugly site.
Just because the girls are ugly doesn't mean the site has to be.
Why not go for a cleaner look where the surfer gets to know some of the models a little. What you should be selling is these models as "real" people who the surfer becomes curious about.
Look how they do it on
http://www.mikesapartment.com or
http://www.cumfiesta.com
These people know what they're doing!