Brett,
It's an interesting choice. I don't know which would be more effective. For the specific choice you mentioned, reaching only 300 of our webmasters would be too small a percentage. Of course, reaching THE CORRECT 300 webmasters might be really valuable.
I'm adding a line in the webmaster database right now, "Likes Kid Rock"!
------------------
TGP2 Bucks. $1/email. No deductions!
The Neon Jungle!