i searched USENET, fagtastic first shows up in 1998 on the Dr. Laura newsgroup.
From: reverse fried egg (----------------------)
Subject: Re: The Day Is Coming Nearer!
View: Complete Thread (6 articles)
Original Format
Newsgroups: alt.radio.talk.dr-laura
Date: 1998/12/12
[email protected] (Wonafan) wrote:
>reverse fried egg keeps it short and sweet :
>>I see the caps are back, fag.
>
>You're fagtastic.
Your response fairly begs the use of a homograph. I'd have say you
have a queer way of looking at things, at least if you actually
approve of my deliberately annoying fruitly belabors and rebuttals.