If you have this guy dead to rights, contractually speaking, unplug him now without redirecting and tell him you'll see him in court. A convincing bluff frequently does the job. He'll shit his pants when his traffic starts getting those "The page cannot be displayed" errors (I'm not totally sure on the wording).
As for redirecting his traffic, why damage your karma? Take the high road. Just my opinion.
------------------
Producer of truly original teen/young woman-oriented adult content at
Wonders of the Unseen World