Wow, PIB cash won't have a bunch of newbies who sign up and send 1 join a month, or sig whores flying their ref code on GFY, big deal. I doubt they've lost any real business over this. Offering to let top affiliates look at their admin area and having a 3rd party do audits is a lot more proof to me than screenshots from some scumbag trying to scam $1000 from webmasters and an employee who got the boot.
Talking about jimmy3way's part in this, he said he had real proof and he'd show it for a grand. He would've taken the money if someone offered it right away. How would you feel if you paid $1000 for that most likely fake screenshot? That's a scam.