Awe, fuck, these are all nice buttons and thanks to everyone who entered.
The 4 that grab me the most are (in random order):
and
and
and
The other buttons were nice too, but damn, I'm trying to pick just one.
Let me sleep on it; I'll announce tomorrow! Barring any other entries I'll pick one of these for the $100 winner and offer the other 3 runners up $25 each for their button.