Neriah, I can't remember if I mentioned this to you the other night when we were chatting but keep this rule of thumb in mind.
In this business, the quality of your traffic is more important to your success than the quality of your designs.
So don't get overly focused on creating a perfect museum of art on your site for everyone to go gah gah over. Any of these would work great and get the job done.
Here's what I would do since all seven of the finalists created great looking pages, each in their own style. Test and rotate them all out on your site and see what pages generate the most 2nd page clicks and then on to becoming membership sales. You might be surprised. Sometimes really different looks, like TheFly's for example can pull better than the ultra photoshop glam style the other designs have. You just never know til you see how they work once deployed.
But like I said, at the end of the day they are buying You and that design that God created is already perfection.
