Mindi, Again, nice automatation. I do alot of automation too as mentioned so I am interested in this kind of stuff.
I noticed in your Search Console screenshot that many of your top rankings are for specific restaurant names like "labetto", "le vita", "levetta pizza". When I check these in Google Keyword Planner and similar tools, they show very low/zero search volume.
Could you share some examples of your rankings for higher-volume discovery keywords like "best restaurants in brantford" or "italian restaurants brantford"? Those are typically the queries that drive actual traffic and business leads.
For reference, here's a search for one of the competitive terms:
https://www.google.com/search?q=best...s+in+brantford
Where does your site show up for queries like these?