Did you keep track anywhere of referrals? Meaning do you know where the traffic was coming from before so that you can compare it to where it is coming from now?
That might tell you a lot.
You say you pretty much killed the clones. Is it possible that some of the clones included links to you that you have now killed?
Just some ideas to look at that have nothing to do with whether your set up is right or now.
.
|