Originally Posted by mineistaken

I was like - hmm, if he did not say 2 girls I would believe those are just one

On the unrelated note - sometimes you can see at the same girl and have no idea it is the same, dude to different makeup or whatever It does not happen when a girl has distinctive features, but some (even hot) girls have common features, so add different makeup and completely different girl. You can differentiate her only after you meet her in person. If not - you can be easily tricked