Originally Posted by blackmonsters

But why couldn't you pick a case that had the same circumstances in reality.

One case involved a 17 yr old boyfriend of the daughter in the house and male versus male.

The other case involved a grown man with a restraining order against him for domestic violence. This is male versus female.

Some people might think that shooting a gun to "scare away" the 17 yr old boyfriend was more a display of power simply to threaten rather than a need to defend.

Not even the same kind of case.