Quote:
Originally Posted by gideongallery
so the guy who arguing for government granted control over distribution is calling me a communist.
free market says that all products should compete without any government controls.
The dictates of social responsibility dictate the government involvement to protect the PUBLIC good.
In a true free market copyright would not be allowed to exist, in a socially responsible free market copyright would only allowed to exist as long as it does not infringe on things like free speech
Including such "insane" concepts of "this is the best dance routine i have every scene"
statements by the copyright holder that i am to stupid to figure out how to make money in a world where people could use my content in that concept would not be valid justifications for voiding the free speech.
Really want to tell my how many times I have said "that won't work in porn" when someone presented an example of a solution to the problem.
130 million dollars was raised by crowd funding this year by kickstarter alone.
let me guess "that won't work in porn" |
But just adding a line "this is the best dance routine i have every scene" is not fair use commentary.
Spelling and grammar issues aside, you aren't actually providing commentary. You are giving an opinion, but no explanation or commentary as to why that opinion has merit. You are also not using this clip to enhance some greater point you are trying to make. If you used this clip along with 10 other clips of dance routines that are not as good as this one and your analysis of why that is would be valid commentary.
Of course you know this already because you likely tried this and got your ass busted for it by Youtube. You uploaded what appears to be the entire Daily Show bit on SOPA and probably tried to add a line like "this is the best SOPA explanation I have ever seen" and you instantly got it taken taken down.
If all you had to do was add this little line and everything suddenly was fair use I could upload the full movie Unforgiven and just say, "This is the best western movie I have ever seen." With that all would be good, but that is not how it works.