Quote:
Originally Posted by Due
Really ? So now your file sharing is OK because you can package sniff the data otherwise from cablevision ?
I already explained the difference in how it's recorded, distributed and stored. I never said any data had to be with a specific corporate or private entity to be considered a private copy.
|
and i never said that you did
we are talking about the PUBLIC transmission not the private copy
again the judege ruled and the supreme court upheld
Quote:
that making a private copy from a Public transmission was still entitled to fair use protection based on the use of that private copy
how exactly is the transmission public if as you claim it only fair use if it controled by a single company.
|
the public internet is the public transmission part of the cablevision cloud
the swarm is the public transmission part of torrent cloud.
you argued that second public transmission invalidates the fair use right because of a lack of control
the same lack of control exists in the cable vision public transmission based on the very design of tcp/ip.
you keep dodging the question because you know it proves your wrong
Quote:
|
how exactly is the transmission public if as you claim it only fair use if it controled by a single company.
|