Quote:
Originally Posted by Due
No I said make money on a thief. I guess you associated the thief to be all P2P users, what does that say about you ?
|
no you did not you started posting how i did not have a right to timeshift shows i paid for because i was sharing (distributing) as well
your exact words
Quote:
The problem is usually that when you download it you share it hence you serve it to people who may not have paid for this tv show.
That's distribution of copyrighted material. Buying a TV show doesn't give you the right to share it.
|
you point blank attacked timeshifting via a cloud
Quote:
I'm sorry I did not fully read through your reference, I have now and this is one of the key points
The way the Cablevision system was designed, every time a consumer decided to record a given show, Cablevision would store a separate copy of that program, and each of those copies could be played back only by the consumer who recorded i
When you seed in the swarm you
1: Do not know if the user is allowed to view this copy
2: The same copy can be viewed by multiple users
3: Each consumer have not recorded their own program
On top of that, from a memorandum I have from several years ago you cannot make a copy of a tv show available to a user of a cloud (remote) DVR that was recorded previous to the user requesting it, it must be recorded AFTER the request was made and recorded for that user specifically. (this may be wrong or have changed, I do not know but that's what I would go based on)
|
read the case moron because you making arguement that have already been ruled invalid
the arguement that public components invalidate the right was denied (they argued it wasn't good enough because it didn't have a hard line between the house and the data center)
the fact is every arguement you just made has already been invalidated in that case
secondly the highlighted person is dead wrong
you do not play the same copy
if i paused my copy it would not pause for anyone in the swarm
the court case defined the distinction between public transmission and public broadcast
making a private copy from a public transmission was ruled to be legal
that exactly what both swarm and the cablevision system does
a local copy is made, that local copy is played, only one site plays each local copy.