I've had my eye on this one from ikea for a while:
http://www.ikea.com/us/en/catalog/products/80117765
It's super comfy (especially if you ever sit indian style in your chair) I'm not too hip on the price though. Ikea always has a huge after xmas sale, maybe if they mark it down this year I'll finally pick it up.
It's not that I cringe at paying that much for an office chair, I just think if I'm gonna drop that much change I should get a choice of fabrics. Gray wool doesn't really do it for me. Chair would be alot hotter in white or black leatherette.