[QUOTE=gideongallery;17752760]in response to you claiming that his actions were a copyright violation simply because he had a record contract (since were trying to claim the COPYRIGHT based takedown was valid)
in which case the fair use of commentary is relevent to your arguement (unrelated to my original complaint of anti trust) since it justified the posting even IF he signed a contract.
Quote:
exactly you dragged it away from anti-trust to copyright by claiming the him signing a contract completely and absolutely took away his right to post (the record company was justified in putting in a block filter on everyone including him)
i address that issue to (commentary) to get it back to the anti trust.
|
I just said he may have had a contract the prevented him from posting it. You are the one that then created a bunch of other arguments over it. There is no use in arguing fair use in this case. The case is over. Did you read the article? It was a mistake and video is up. There is no anti-trust. There is no free speech issue. There is no fair use issue. There was a mistake made, Bieber overreacted as 15 year old kids (and you) often do and now everything is fine.
There really is nothing left to talk about here.
Quote:
yup took the screen shot on the day i said i would post if doc agreed to do the deal as we had originally agreed (he doing 100% of day to day operations)
i know you and him both tried to justify him acting like a pussy and backing out of what he agreed to do, but i gain nothing by post it.
|
This is 100% pure and utter horseshit! You know it. You have zero credibility. All you would have to do is black out any potentially sensitive material in the email that you don't want people to see and post the screen shots that shows you made this offer to him and he accepted it. The problem is this is about the third or fourth version of the story. First there was no response. Then you said you sent it but he never replied. Then you said you sent it and he tried to change the deal. Now you won't post it because you have nothing to gain. The deal is dead. It is never going to happen, but you can make yourself look like something more than a self-righteous schizophrenic who feels entitled to everyone's content without paying for it if you just post the email. Just black out everything but you making the offer as you claim you did and his reply backing out. Post it and the header and maybe you could gain a little credibility. But you won't because we both know there is no email.