Quote:
Originally Posted by kane
But uploading a song to youtube and putting the phrase "Check out my new video" is not legit fair use commentary. It isn't commentary at all. It is asking people to watch/listen to your new video.
|
says the guy who is so fundamentally clueless about copyright law and fair use that you argued copyright holders have complete control over how their music can and can not be used no matter if that action censors free speech or not
sort of strange given the fact that the constitution says that congress doesn't have the right to make laws that do that, and copyright act is a congress created law.
the only condition on if something is fair use or not is if it meets the 4 conditions of fair use
which puts this action (censoring commentary on one medium vs another) clearly in the censorship position.
he was able to post the video on facebook, just not on youtube
it the selective authorization that the anti-trust violation get it thru you head.
your dodging the issue, just like you did the last time we had this debate
http://www.gofuckyourself.com/showth...+s ues&page=4
Quote:
|
It doesn't change the reality of the world. If you sign a contract that says you can't upload your new music to YouTube, Facebook or whatever then that is what you have to stick by. It isn't worth arguing with you over what is fair use and what isn't because you have a warped sense of reality. We will never see eye to eye on it,
|
Quote:
|
The simple fact of matter is this: If you sign a contract, you have to stick by it. If you sign a record contact and they control who you upload to and who you don't than that is how it works. You knew this when you signed the contract, you knew this when you took all their money. You can't suddenly change your mind and decide now that you have millions in the bank you want to no longer abide by the contract.
|
so the fact that you can't legally contract away fair use has nothing to do with your arguement that JB has to obey the contract even though it basically TOS away his fair use rights (to his own shit btw).
