The reason I picked #3 over the first two is this:
#1: Too much information. It's info overload in a hard to follow zig-zag pattern, not enough focus on image/video content. Unfortunately, that flaw is a big one, so that's where I stopped considering this one.
#2: Better. Better info wrap up top but falls apart on the lower section, still quite a ton of info, and there are a number of technical design flaws.
#3: Of the three, this one is the most image/video content focused. Less "noise" overall. i.e. less menu tabs, (I know there's a sub-menu, but it's still better) less life story, etc... It's concise. Good natural info wrap all around, no wandering eyeballs. There are less technical design flaws and are only minor and virtually unnoticeable. It's not perfect, and could be improved, but is the best choice of the three options. (In my opinion. That doesn't mean my opinion is right.)
Getting the main video trailer box up a little higher would be helpful I think. And remember, strokers just need a little written encouragement on the main page, not a full biography. Bios and stuff can come after page 1 if they're interested in that stuff.
For what it's worth, never make a surfer "fight" or struggle to get through your tour. You want a nice smooth curving flow of key elements, get him worked up, get his dick in his hand and get him to that box where he puts his credit card number in, as fast as possible. I usually try to accomplish as much of this as I can in the top 1/3rd of the page 1 design if possible. If you don't sink your hooks in there, your odds go down dramatically from there on.
