Quote:
Originally Posted by TheDoc
I quoted the wiki as to the reason your example fell under fair use and why that is vastly different than Robbie's example.. whatever the various, the many reasons that make your example fair use, is why your example is not the same as what robbie gave.
|
no you didn't
you shifted from one fair use to another
robbie and i were talking about parody
he argued that parodies were not parodies unless they were created from scratch
downfall proved he was wrong
you switched fair uses and tried to argue that downfall example was fair use because it was a sample, actually trying to argue that all parodies must be sample to be valid.
you were wrong
i can take an entire score that is copyright protected / or an entire music video and layer in a parody track instead and it would still be covered by the fair use of parody
sampling is a complete different fair use.
you then changed fair use again trying to argue that the only fair uses that allow the entire file to be used was for personal use (misrepresenting private viewing as personal use)
again you were wrong because cablevision win proves that statement to be wrong too
personal use = private viewing.