Quote:
Originally Posted by GatorB
yeah and? My gas tank only holds 15 gallons so if I bring some gas containers I can "timeshift" gas from someone's car then.
|
Quote:
|
If you scratch your DVD guess what you're shit out of luck. I guess that means you can steal another one form wal-mart.
|
only if your a world class moron to stupid to understand the words
Quote:
|
deprive the rightful owner of it
|
which anyone with a 4th grade reading and comprehension level understands is exactly what you are doing when you take gas from someone elses car.
Quote:
Also when you "time shift" it's not supposed to be FOREVER. If you watched a "time shifted" episode and you don't have enough room DELETE IT.
kind of the point Einstein. Not sure where it says you are allowed to "timeshift" the entirety of the history of television.
|
really want to show me a vcr that stopped playing an old tape after a certain time limit.
you are talking about taking away rights that the old technology gave you.
How stupid do you have to be to think that is legitimate.
Quote:
|
When you pay your cable bill you are paying to have access to that show AT THAT TIME. Not to have PERMANENT copy of it.
|
your actually trying to use the arguement that was over ruled in the betamax case to justify your position
if it was only allowed to be watched at that time, then moving it to another time would have been equally illegal.
The content producers in that case claimed that they licienced the content for "viewing on that specific day at that specific time" when they tried to argue that moving it to another day was a copyright infrignement.
The supreme court ruled against them.
Quote:
|
WOW I am contnually amazed at people in this industry that are so against the pirating of THIER content and bitch about tubes, torrents and such and yet think that downloading a torrent of their favorite TV show is ok because it's "timeshifting". I'm not sure if all these people are hypocrites or just retarded.
|
the only hypocrite here is you, since you refuse to pay me for your hosting again, but demand that i pay twice for my content (using an arguement that the court have already ruled invalid
)
you believe it unfair for me to ask you to pay twice for the same service but you have no problem demanding that i do.
Quote:
|
Just so we are clear if you pay a monthly cable bill that entitles your to a free copy of every TV show because it's unfair for you to pay twice. So logically if someone is paying for a monthly subscription to a porn site he should be allowed to have a perrmanent copy of all the content on that site beause he's already paid for it.
|
they do as so long as the content in question was available during the term of the membership
if you grant them full access to everything you have ever produced the copyright act (thru the fair use section) grants them the right to back it up and time shifting etc.
You need to keep the content fresh so they have a justification to keep comming back.