Amateur doesn't mean ugly though... Guys like to see that some effort went into the production, I think..
NOw she could look like that and be gagging/puking on the cock.. and you be calling her a crack whore while you cock slap her face.. guys will buy that.
But there ain't no way in hell the fantasy of a goddess or anything heavenly is going to go with something not well constructed or put together.
And ANY chick can be hot. I can take a roley-poley BBW.. and with some mystic tan, great stockings, great hair, well structured lingerie... and turn her into an amazon man eating Goddess...
Just the same as you can take a regular joe-blow meth addict chick.. put her in some MAC, sexy clothes, and fix her hair.. and make her a desirable 8-9.
Make up, image, and hygiene are what makes the model.
Even if amateur.