dude it's a lot easier, cheaper, and more profitable to sell these tickets on ebay than to drive to jersey or another borough and deliver them...i don't get what you were thinkin...now your last chance to get a decent price is craigslist....
I can only offer to cut your losses with a lowball of like fifty bucks if you don't get rid of them by the day of the show. It's really the best show on broadway even though it hasn't been 'hot' for more than a decade. Awesome music. It's the first thing my parents and I seen on broadway upon coming to America. We had the fucking soundtrack to that and jesus christ superstar before we even got here. Andrew LLoyd Webbeer was the shit
But alas, I've seen it once and my parents have seen it twice so good luck with it...you should put it up on craigslist like right now!