Hi Toni,
There's a GFY Thread titled: "ProxyPass and PhantomFrog, Anyone ran both?"
You can find it here:
https://gfy.com/fucking-around-and-business-discussion/764648-proxypass-phantomfrog-ran.html
In that thread, you'll find a host of very satisfied Frog clients who
have used both and provide detailed responses.
On our website, there's a page dedicated to providing a clear
illustration and case study of why systems which rely on IP counting
(like ProxyPass and Pennywize) are ineffective and outdated.
Http://www.PhantomFrog.com/g
Click on Learn page / Go to lower right hand corner of page for info
In fact, in some cases, these tools actually make life easier for hackers
because they know they get a certain number of password dictionary
guesses per anonymous IP via brute forcing. Even Ray will attest to this.
Now, the sure fire way for you to make your decision is to actually
be able to run ProxyPass against Frog side-by-side.
That capability exists with our Free Trial which sets up in 5 minutes!!!
Our Trial demonstrates the superior pass abuse detection capability of
Frog's Geo-IP feature. In fact, you'll be blown away by the abuse which
is detected by Frog but "flys beneath the radar" of ProxyPass.
To learn more about Phantom Frog, please visit:
Http://www.PhantomFrog.com/g
To setup a Free Trial:
http://phantomfrog.com/g?ft=1
Since the Trial is free, the only risk you run is discovering a better
solution for protecting your site(s).
Please do not hesistate to contact me with any further questions
and please feel free to check out our webmaster testimonials page.