Originally Posted by tyler (durden)

I thought it was great - smart dialogue (Ed. WTF? dialogue isn't a word according to spell check), genuinely likable characters, not you're typical high school romance story, and a good ending. It was a overly cheesy at times and most people I've talked with about it agree that the beginning was pretty bad so I was a little more than shocked to see it nominated for Oscars.

I wouldn't think it can really be enjoyed by the majority of people over 25. It's weird that everyone is comparing it to Garden State. Maybe it's the Indie subculture thing. I guess if you aren't into Indie Music or Film then you would have a harder time enjoying this.