Hoax: You're point is completely valid and I totally agree. That's why I started this discussion centering on exclusive gallery templates.
But in regards to the templates at sexplanet: the cost is so inexpensive that it would be affordable to get a membership and pick out the "gems" (if there are any). One "gem" a month would more than cover the cost of the membership.
But yes, I'm mostly interested in exclusive premade templates that the designer took the time to match the message with the sites it's promoting. Even willing to pay a premium over and above what a custom gallery template costs because the designer took the time to make it before it was sold he should reap an extra reward.
And designers, don't contact me saying you will premake templates for me. That's not what this discussion is about. It's about a site (or sites) dedicated to it. Not just for me but for all webmasters. Instead of making them for me, make a site and list them so everyone can see and be able to purchase them!
Roxane