We tested both systems ages back and went for GXbill. Bottom line is we generate more revenue through them. I have nothing bad to say about the companys mentioned in this thread, suppose its just what works for you.
GXbill also easy to install and easy for the end user to use. Plus GX support is really good. Fast replys to emails or instant on ICQ .
My 10 cents
-------------
www.SpankBuxx.com