Originally Posted by u-Bob

Good idea if your objective is to go after the other torrent sites' SE traffic.

A "Fake" torrent site like the one you described will never be able to compete with "real" torrent sites for expert torrent users.

A "Fake" torrent site that shows up in the SERPS will however be able to attract a decent number of n00b torrent users (the kind that heard about torrents but doesn't really know what it is).

I've said this before: One of the ways to go after torrent sites is to stop their supply of new users, the ones that are coming from SEs. Just imagine if the first 50 SERPS for torrent related terms were filled with links to fake torrent sites (maybe even filled with tons of popups or 'corrupt' 600 meg files of garbage)....