Quote:
Originally Posted by Kevin-SFBucks
Even one violation is breaking the law.
you are using the numbers and I don't believe you are accurate. I am looking for the information.
I am still waiting for you to point me to where in section 106 and 107 or any case law where it says you can act in any capacity to distribute copyrighted material.
I gave you in 106 where I get to retain my distribution rights... where's the support on your side?
|
and i am still waiting for your answer to my last question
Tell you what answer my question and i will answer your (again)
Quote:
BTW torrents don't need trackers to share files i suggest you look up DHT.
since the torrent file does not contain any copyright material and doesn't contain any trade secrets should it be protected by the copyright laws as well
I can write books telling people how to do illegal things( like making bombs), i can write software that can potentially be used to do illegal things(like cracking dvd encryption). All of those are protected by both copyright law and first ammendment rights. If your right and your copyright allows control of distribution of your work, doesn't the torrent creator have the same right to protect his copyright.
Wouldn't you be violating his copyright to protect your own WHEN YOU CAN PERFECTLY PROTECT YOUR COPYRIGHT by going after the SEEDERS DIRECTLY.
Your arguement about how strong your copyright protection is flawed because you seem to want to ignore "fair use" the problem is even if i seed the point (which i am only doing to make the point because your assessment about the lack of power of "fair use" is dead wrong) then the .torrent file should be entitled to the same incontrovertible protection as well.
your arguement is flawed because if you are correct about how perfect your protection is targeting the .torrent files is violation of their copyright
|
if your arguement is correct and the copyright is so strong
why is the act of trying to take away the .torrent files creator not a violation of their copyright
remember the file has no copyrighted material in it, and has no trade secrets since it based on an open spec.