Quote:
|
everyone else is under the same restricted license with NO RIGHTS FOR REDISTRIBUTION. They have the same restricted rights that you had in watching it.
|
you assume that they have no right to distribute to people who have purchased a licienced right to view WITHOUT PROOF.
You ignore the fact that BETAMAX case actually recognized this right by not requiring VCRs to have an encoding schema that would have prevented the playing on another device.
You ignore the fact that when i am recovering my data from an online backup i am reaquiring a lost copy of said material.
VCRs without an ecoding schema that would prevent their playing on another VCR would be illegal if you were right.
Online backup would be illegal if you were right.
it is another A-B-A proof again and you know it
I will make it simple for you
Why did the BETAMAX case not result in a ruling that the technology was invalid until they implemented an encoding schema that prevented it from playing it on another device. If you were correct and the ruling DID NOT give me the right to aquire a missed copy from a friend such a ruling would be 100% legitimate.