Originally Posted by gideongallery

I have repeatedly said you should go after the INFRINGING SEEDER directly

This is a perfect example of such an INFRINGING SEEDER

She had no fair use right to the content because she had not aquired any rights to the content

She did not buy the CD with those songs, she did not buy those tracks from itunes, rapsody or any of the song by song download sites.

Compare it with my tv example, i bought the rights to the tv shows by buying the cable subscription.

If you don't get this exactly the type of case i am arguing you SHOULD FIGHT. The RIAA did not sue KAZZA they sued the individual who was actually INFRINGING on their copyright.