Hi Maggie.
DVDs For A Buck and
Gay DVDs For A Buck look like a nice fit with your site.
DFAB is an Adult Movie Club that let's the customer choose the DVDs they'd like to add to their collection. It's not a rental program. We've got several niches that would fit with what you are offering.
If you've got any questions, please contact me, we've got a new functionality that would also work really well with your traffic.