Originally Posted by jimmy-3-way

So, among my vast collection of rides I have a station wagon which I use as a grocery getter. A while back a chuck of rock flew off a dump truck and cracked the windshield. Little did I know my old lady neglected to get glass cover on this particular hooptie.

Anyway I called the glass place and ordered a new windshield, which a guy came out and replaced yesterday. After the job I was ready to pay him and he says, "Oh I guess they might have quoted you the wrong price...instead of $220 it's like uh...$180." So I inspected the job, kicked him $200, the $180 and tip.

Later I noticed that during the job he'd fucked up my car by using a screw driver to pry off some trim tabs and breaking them. Then, he'd hidden his crime by jamming the tabs back in, but the first time I drove the car they vibrated out.

Now I think he KNEW he was guilty and thus gave me the discount.

So what would YOU do in this situation?