Real Sex Cash has exactly what you're looking for. We have a couple hardcore amateur sites all with free movie content:
www.amateurandhomemadeporn.com - general amateur video
www.annasucks.com - amateur deepthroat solo girl
www.kims-amateurs.com - amateur mature
www.realcouples.co.uk - real amateur couples shot professionally
www.yourchoicemovies.com - amateur wives and couples
Edit: Forgot to mention that right now we only have WMV clips BUT we can re-encode them to your needs.